Last week I had the good luck to see an advanced screening of
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World, two weeks before release. To channel Knives Chau (the 17-year-old version):
OMG IT WAS
AWESOME!!!1!1!!
Co-writers Edgar Wright (also director) and Michael Bacall did an admirable job of condensing over 1200 pages of comics into a breezy, flowing, not disjointed, 2 hour movie. This was a passion project for Edgar Wright - in interviews from Comic-Con he mentioned working on it for the past five years, as each of the books came out. The editing - both of the film and of the epic story - was very well done.
Yes, there are large chunks of the original comic story excised, including most of the high school flashback sequences, and people associated with them. Each of the battles against an Evil Ex has been compressed somewhat, and does not always follow the exact same action as the comic (alas, no
Honest Ed’s). People who love the books (like the group of teenagers sitting behind me quoting lines from the series until the movie started) are likely going to be angry “this” or “that” or “the other thing” is missing from the movie. (And to be honest, a sequence that contained one my favorite panels in the entire series didn’t make the cut. Spoiler alert: Scroll down to the very bottom of this post to see it.) However, that’s always the case when a much adored book or series is adapted to the screen (e.g.,
Watchmen, the Harry Potter series, the Bourne novels). So, SP fans expecting a carbon copy of the comic are bound to be disappointed. Those who understand the challenges of adapting comics to film and are willing to let the director tell Bryan Lee O’Malley’s story in his own way will be much rewarded.
I actually am a bit envious of people seeing
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World who haven’t read any of the comics. Not only can they enjoy the film without mentally comparing “what’s missing”, if they decide to start reading the books, they have an awesome experience waiting for them, almost like reading a “director’s cut”.
Honestly, I had my doubts about Michael Cera playing Scott Pilgrim from the moment he was cast. He just didn’t seem ADHD enough to play the scattered Scott, who is far less emo than Cera’s persona. However, it did work, and at times I actually forgot that I was watching the same mopey, wimpy kid from
Juno,
Superbad, and
Arrested Development. The rest of the roles are also perfectly cast. Standouts include Alison Pill as the snarky, sarcastic, long-suffering Kim Pine; Kieran Culkin as gay BFF and (non-sexual) sharer of Scott’s bed; Oscar nominee Anna Kendrick in a small role as the wise Stacey Pilgrim; and of course modern day scream queen Mary Elizabeth Winstead as heroine Ramona Flowers.
Toronto is put to excellent use in the film, as it had been in the comics. I missed Toronto so much while watching this! I was a Torontoian for too brief of a time, and have thought about moving back. (Although, I always wondered - especially after the completing the nearly three year immigration process to move to Canada legally - how did Ramona (an American) land a job with Amazon.ca so easily?) The soundtrack is also quite fun, with original contributions from Beck and Metric, plus select songs from T. Rex, the Rolling Stones, and Plumtree (originators of the song “Scott Pilgrim”).
Here’s what I Twittered immediately after the preview:
(MSM = Mainstream media)
Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World is probably going to meet the same fate the excellent
Kick-Ass did earlier this year. Comic book readers, geeks, gamers, and their ilk will see it, love it, and tell their friends... who likely were already planning to see it, anyway.
The mainstream (as in not web-based, but more traditionally print) media will likely say that the movie needs a huge dose of Ritalin, is too frenetic, and an example of the deteriorating attention spans of this country’s youth. The first week it opens, it will likely land around the middle of the Top 10 list, and then fall further each week. It’s opening on a rough day - 8/13 - against the testosterone-fest
The Expendables (which I actually want to see), and the castrating
Eat Pray Love (which, if it was a choice between watching that movie and eating spoiled potato salad, bring me my spork and barf bucket). I do plan on seeing Scott Pilgrim again during its first week, because I want to support not only Edgar Wright, but also the creator of the entire universe, Bryan Lee O’Malley.
Until 8/13, amuse yourself with some Scott Pilgrim related fun!
Awesome cool SP tributes:
Hey Pais: Scott Pilgrim Costumes by Paisley Cat
A Life Like Scott Pilgrim by Liz Prince
Mashup: Google map, photos, and panels from
Scott Pilgrim’s Toronto by Ben Spiegel at Sleep is for the Weak, and a
interview with Spiegel.
A Scott Pilgrimage: a photo essay of the Toronto locations in specific panels.
Spoiler Alert: Finally, this is my favorite scene from the comic that didn’t make it into the film, from
Scott Pilgrim Gets it Together (aka Book 4). I was so hoping that Edgar Wright would somehow be able to pull of this incredibly strange, fantastic arrangement of Scott hopping in Ramona’s bag for protection.